USA Tourism, A Tourism Site of the United States.

The Top 10 Places to Eat in Shipshewana, Indiana

Shipshewana is a small town in Indiana known for its Amish community, large flea market, and unique dining options. Here are ten places to eat in Shipshewana that you are sure to enjoy.

about matthew
Updated August 10, 2023
Hey there! I'm Matthew, I'm a passionate traveler who loves to explore the US with my family. I'm excited to share my experiences and tips on how to make the most of your trips while traveling in the US.
This article is sponsored by your brand name here.
places to eat in shipshewana indiana
Save this article for later

1. Blue Gate Restaurant & Bakery

Buffet, Mid-Range Meals, Alcohol-Free

Blue Gate Restaurant and Bakery

This renowned spot is celebrated for its Amish-style cooking, taking you on a culinary journey into traditional American heartland cuisine. From fried chicken to a myriad of homemade pies, their offerings epitomize comfort food. The restaurant combines a warm, traditional ambiance with hearty meals, making it a must-visit for those keen on a genuine Amish dining experience.

Why We Recommend

Blue Gate Restaurant & Bakery in Shipshewana offers a delightful buffet with an array of options, including specialties like smoked pork and fried chicken, catering even to gluten and dairy-free preferences. The Amish Country ambiance, coupled with their friendly service, onsite bakery, theater, and charming mini-shops, make it a must-visit for both its scrumptious meals and unique dining experience.

See what people are saying in their Google Reviews.

Contact Information

Phone Number: (260) 768-4725

Address: 195 N Van Buren St, Shipshewana, IN 46565

Service Options: Dine-in · Takeout

2. East of Chicago Pizza

Pizzeria, Budget Friendly, Alcohol-Free

East of Chicago Pizza

Although part of a regional chain, East of Chicago Pizza maintains a distinct identity with its diverse pizza offerings. Their menu boasts a variety of pizzas, wings, and other casual dishes that cater to a broad spectrum of tastes. The relaxed environment and family-friendly setting make it a preferred choice for many.

Why We Recommend

East of Chicago Pizza delivers an authentic Chicago-style experience, with their deep dish pizzas standing out as a family favorite. With offerings ranging from garlic cheese bread and Parm pops to steak subs and perfectly spiced wings, this eatery guarantees fresh, delicious meals complemented by their attentive staff and efficient delivery team. Their buffet, featuring diverse pizzas and a salad bar, alongside special lunchtime flash pan pizzas, ensures there’s something for everyone.

See what people are saying in their Google Reviews.

Contact Information

Phone Number: (260) 768-7272

Address: 350 S Van Buren St # C, Shipshewana, IN 46565

Service Options: Dine-in · Takeout · Delivery

3. Jojo’s Pretzels

Pretzels, Budget Friendly, Alcohol-Free

Jojos Pretzels

JoJo’s is more than just a pretzel shop; it’s an experience. With their signature hand-rolled pretzels, gourmet mustards, and diverse range of dips, it’s a snack-lover’s paradise. The establishment oozes casual charm, making it a perfect quick-stop to satiate those mid-day cravings.

Why We Recommend

Jojo’s Pretzels stands out for its delectable range of pretzels, with popular flavors like parmesan, cinnamon sugar, and original consistently winning over patrons, both new and longtime. Paired with their signature dips like cheese and cream, and backed by friendly service, these pretzels offer a satisfying and memorable experience, making it a must-visit for anyone in Shipshe.

See what people are saying in their Google Reviews.

Contact Information

Phone Number: (260) 768-7759

Address: 225 N Harrison St, Shipshewana, IN 46565

Service Options: Dine-in · Takeout

4. 5/20 Country Kitchen

American, Budget Friendly, Alcohol-Free

5 20 Country Kitchen

Embarking on a nostalgic journey of American cuisine with Amish and Mennonite roots, this kitchen offers an authentic experience. Their menu is packed with comfort foods, served in a welcoming, down-to-earth environment. It’s a place where tradition meets taste, especially during breakfast and lunch hours.

Why We Recommend

5/20 Country Kitchen delivers an authentic home-cooked experience, with dishes like their reminiscent fried chicken and perfectly cooked sweet potato fries that are sure to evoke nostalgia. Paired with outstanding service, notably from staff like Kayla, and fair pricing, this establishment promises a delightful dining experience, though vegetarian options are limited.

See what people are saying in their Google Reviews.

Contact Information

Phone Number: (260) 768-4958

Address: 7995 US-20, Shipshewana, IN 46565

Service Options: Dine-in · Takeout

advertisment

5. Shipshewana Auction Restaurant

Diner, Budget Friendly, Alcohol-Free

Shipshewana Auction Restaurant

Conveniently located within the bustling Shipshewana Auction & Flea Market grounds, this restaurant is a refuge for shoppers seeking a hearty meal. Offering classic American comfort foods, it specializes in breakfast and lunch dishes. The casual setting combined with the quick service makes it an ideal choice for a mid-shopping break.

Why We Recommend

Shipshewana Auction Restaurant is renowned for its top-notch dishes, from their freshly made biscuits and gravy to the best burgers in town. Offering a variety of home-cooked meals, especially their must-have chicken & noodles, and exquisite desserts, this establishment ensures a delightful dining experience, but do remember to visit early as they close at 2:00 PM.

See what people are saying in their Google Reviews.

Contact Information

Phone Number: (260) 336-8362

Address: 345 S Van Buren St, Shipshewana, IN 46565

Service Options: Dine-in · Takeout

6. Rise’n Roll Bakery & Deli

Bakery, Budget Friendly, Alcohol-Free

Rise n Roll Bakery and Deli

A testament to Amish culinary artistry, Rise ‘n Roll is celebrated for its donuts, pastries, and an array of baked goods. Beyond baked treats, they also serve sandwiches and various deli items. The establishment expertly blends the atmosphere of a bakery and cafe, making every visit memorable.

Why We Recommend

Rise’n Roll Bakery & Deli, originating from humble beginnings, now stands as a must-visit destination in Amish country, boasting an array of delectable baked goods including their renowned cinnamon caramel donuts. Coupled with its warm hospitality, exemplified by its friendly owner, this bakery offers an array of mouth-watering treats such as the “Amish Crack,” ensuring every visit is memorable.

See what people are saying in their Google Reviews.

Contact Information

Phone Number: (574) 825-4032

Address: 1065 N 1150 W, Middlebury, IN 46540

Service Options: Dine-in · Takeout

advertisment

7. Ben’s Soft Pretzels

Pretzel, Mid-Range Meals, Alcohol-Free

Bens Soft Pretzels

Inspired by Amish recipes, Ben’s Soft Pretzels has earned acclaim for its soft, flavorful creations. Their pretzels, complemented by a variety of dips, offer a unique snacking experience. Although they have multiple locations, the quality and taste remain consistently impeccable.

Why We Recommend

Ben’s Soft Pretzels offers an impeccable fusion of buttery, soft, and perfectly salted pretzels that are both delightful to the palate and the eye. With a diverse menu, including the irresistible ham and cheese pretzel pocket, and a mission to feed a hungry child with every purchase, this bakery in Shipshewana is more than just a treat – it’s an experience worth reliving every time you’re in the area.

See what people are saying in their Google Reviews.

Contact Information

Phone Number: (260) 768-4939

Address: 100 Berkshire Dr, Shipshewana, IN 46565

Service Options: In-store

8. The Bread Box Bakery & Cafe

Bakery, Budget Friendly, Alcohol-Free

The Bread Box Bakery and Cafe

The Bread Box offers a delightful range of homemade breads, pastries, and sandwiches. It’s an ideal destination for a light breakfast or lunch, serving everything fresh. The cafe’s warm atmosphere is complemented by the aroma of freshly baked goods.

Why We Recommend

The Bread Box Bakery and Cafe in Shipshewana, IN, offers a heartwarming experience with its exceptional service, delightful ambiance, and a broad range of freshly made dishes, including the unforgettable bacon egg croissant sandwich. With an expansive selection of homemade baked goods, from cinnamon rolls to the highly-recommended lemon bars, as well as a variety of delicious sandwiches, this cozy cafe stands out as a must-visit gem in the heart of Amish country.

See what people are saying in their Google Reviews.

Contact Information

Phone Number: (260) 768-4629

Address: 120 Morton St, Shipshewana, IN 46565

Service Options: Takeout

9. Country Corral Restaurant

Diner, Budget Friendly, Alcohol-Free

Country Corral Restaurant

Embodying the heart of Midwest cooking, Country Corral is known for its buffet-style offerings. With a diverse spread that includes salads, hot entrees, and desserts, it’s a destination for those wanting to sample a bit of everything. The welcoming atmosphere and friendly service only add to its charm.

Why We Recommend

Country Corral Restaurant in Shipshewana offers a delightful breakfast experience that rivals homemade classics. The delectable dishes, ranging from the eye-popping fruit plate to the irresistibly frosted cinnamon roll, are enhanced by a genuine small-town American diner atmosphere. With warm service, a clean and inviting environment, and some of the best bacon around, it’s a must-visit when in the area.

See what people are saying in their Google Reviews.

Contact Information

Phone Number: (260) 768-4589

Address: 260 E North Village Dr A, Shipshewana, IN 46565

Service Options: Dine-in · Takeout

10. Wana-Cup Restaurant

American, Budget Friendly, Alcohol-Free

Wana Cup Restaurant

This local joint dishes out an array of pizzas, subs, wings, and salads, ensuring diverse options for its patrons. With a commitment to fresh ingredients and flavors, it’s a popular choice for those craving a laid-back dining experience in Shipshewana.

Why We Recommend

Wana-Cup Restaurant in Shipshewana offers a generous serving of freshly made dishes, from abundant grilled chicken salads to flavorful cheeseburgers made from fresh beef. With a combination of prompt service, amicable staff, and a legacy spanning over 45 years, it has consistently met and exceeded customer expectations. Whether you’re a local or passing through, this eatery promises a delicious and hearty meal.

See what people are saying in their Google Reviews.

Contact Information

Phone Number: (260) 768-4923

Address: 295 S Van Buren St, Shipshewana, IN 46565

Service Options: Dine-in · Takeout

About the Author
about matthew
Matthew Mellinger
Hey there! I'm Matthew, and I'm a passionate traveler who loves to explore the US with my family of four. I'm excited to share my experiences and tips on how to make the most of your trips while traveling in the US.
linkedin facebook pinterest youtube rss twitter instagram facebook-blank rss-blank linkedin-blank pinterest youtube twitter instagram