USA Tourism, A Tourism Site of the United States.
Bayfield, Wisconsin
My 10 Favorite Restaurants in Bayfield, Wisconsin

My 10 Favorite Restaurants in Bayfield, Wisconsin

TLDR (too long; didn’t read): Manypenny Bistro is a good spot in the local area for both American and Turkish dishes. Their breakfast is solid, and they’ve got things like wood oven pizzas, gyros, and Turkish Döner for lunch and dinner.

If you’re looking for a place to stay with some great food, check out the Old Rittenhouse Inn‘s restaurant. They’ve got everything from fresh Lake Superior fish to homemade desserts like their rum sundae.

about matthew
Updated August 25, 2023
Hey there! I'm Matthew, I'm a passionate traveler who loves to explore the US with my family. I'm excited to share my experiences and tips on how to make the most of your trips while traveling in the US.
This article is sponsored by your brand name here.
Save this article for later

1. Manypenny Bistro

American, Mid-Range Meals, Alcohol Friendly

Manypenny Bistro

Manypenny Bistro is an innovative restaurant and bakery that offers a unique mix of American and Turkish fare. Located in the local area, the restaurant is known for its delicious breakfast options, which include classic American dishes served with bottomless drip coffee.

For lunch and dinner, Manypenny Bistro offers a variety of wood stone oven pizzas, classic gyros, and Turkish Döner (Doh-ner). For those looking for a sweet treat, the restaurant also features a selection of freshly baked goods that can be enjoyed with a meal or taken to go.

At Manypenny Bistro, diners have the option to dine-in, take-out, or have the food delivered free of charge. With a wide array of options, this restaurant is sure to please.

Why We Recommend

Manypenny Bistro stands out for its delightful culinary offerings, satisfying a wide variety of palates with options ranging from delectable cheeseburgers and gyros to mouth-watering pizzas and unique creations like the grilled badger breakfast sandwich. Its Sunday brunch and breakfast selections, featuring scrumptious dishes like the fluffy mushroom and cheese omelette and the best veggie omelette in Bayfield, are especially cherished. Manypenny Bistro’s dedication to top-notch, friendly service, combined with its comfortable ambiance and reasonable prices, make it a preferred dining spot for locals and visitors alike.

See what people are saying about Manypenny Bistro in their Google Reviews.

Contact Information

Phone Number:  (715) 913-0303

Address: 201 Manypenny Ave, Bayfield, WI 54814

Service Options: Dine-In, Takeout, and Delivery

2. Old Rittenhouse Inn

Fine Dining, Mid-Range Meals, Alcohol Friendly

Old Rittenhouse Inn

The Old Rittenhouse Inn is a beautiful Bayfield, Wisconsin bed and breakfast located on the shores of Lake Superior. Guests can choose from seven guest rooms, each with its own unique charm, and are provided with all the amenities they need for a luxurious stay. The Inn is equipped with a library, parlor, and formal dining room, providing an elegant and peaceful atmosphere. 

The Old Rittenhouse Inn also features The Landmark Restaurant, which serves made-from-scratch upscale American and French cuisine. Guests are invited to enjoy breakfast, lunch, holiday brunches, or gourmet dinners, featuring locally sourced ingredients such as fresh produce and Lake Superior fish, high-quality steaks, poultry, and signature dishes. The full liquor license allows guests to enjoy fine wines, cocktails, specialty drinks, and imported and domestic beers. Guests can finish their meal off with one of the Inn’s homemade desserts, such as a hot fudge, rum, or turtle sundae. 

For those looking for a luxurious stay in a beautiful setting, the Old Rittenhouse Inn is the perfect destination. With its comfortable guest rooms, elegant dining room, and delicious meals, the Old Rittenhouse Inn provides an unforgettable experience.

Why We Recommend

Old Rittenhouse Inn is celebrated for its commendable morning service, offering an extensive selection of breakfast options to kickstart your day. Patrons rave about the exquisite two and three-course breakfasts, which include delightful bakery items accompanied by homemade jam, savory quiches, ham and egg scrambles, and the notable warm blueberry parfait. Despite being robust, the attentive service never falters, ensuring guests’ needs are catered to with utmost care, making this inn a must-visit for those who relish starting their day with a satisfying, flavorful meal.

See what people are saying about the Old Rittenhouse Inn in their Google Reviews.

Contact Information

Phone Number: (715) 779-5111

Address: 301 Rittenhouse Ave, Bayfield, WI 54814

Service Options: Dine-In

3. Starlit Kitchen

Sandwich Shop, Budget Friendly, Alcohol-Free

Starlit Kitchen

Starlit Kitchen is a cozy and inviting eatery located in the heart of Bayfield. With its convenient location on 1st Street, just around the corner from 100 Rittenhouse Avenue, this family-run restaurant offers a wide selection of delicious, freshly made meals and snacks.

At Starlit Kitchen, you can choose from an array of mega-stacked sandwiches, burritos, soups, chili, and sides – all made with healthy ingredients sourced from local farmers and producers. In addition to their tasty entrees, Starlit Kitchen also offers a variety of specialty drinks, snacks and baked goods from their bakery case.

The perfect way to enjoy your Starlit Kitchen meal is to take it to go and explore the beautiful natural sites of Bayfield. Just steps away from the restaurant’s door, you’ll find a picnic spot with an island vista at one of Bayfield’s parks or shorelines. Stop by Starlit Kitchen today for breakfast or lunch, and experience Bayfield’s finest cuisine!

Why We Recommend

Starlit Kitchen is a local gem in Bayfield, known for its prime location by the docks and its fresh, delicious food offered at a reasonable price. You can expect mouth-watering breakfast paninis, creamy burritos, and unique items like smoked trout sandwiches. It’s also a valuable resource for fresh vegetables and baked goods, with high-quality bread available. The outdoor seating provides a cozy atmosphere, while the friendly team enhances the overall experience, making it an attractive choice for a quick bite or a leisurely meal.

See what people are saying about Starlit Kitchen in their Google Reviews.

Contact Information

Phone Number: (715) 913-0315

Address: 100 Rittenhouse Ave, Bayfield, WI 54814

Service Options: Takeout

4. Morty’s Pub

Pub, Mid-Range Meals, Alcohol Friendly

Mortys Pub

Morty’s Pub, located on Rittenhouse Avenue in Bayfield, Wisconsin, is the perfect spot for a cozy night out. With its old-fashioned charm, this pub is sure to make you feel welcomed and right at home.

Morty’s Pub is known for its wide selection of beers, ales, ciders, and a full bar. The pub also offers great food, with delicious daily specials. Customers will be sure to find something to satisfy any craving.

Whether you’re looking for a place to grab a quick bite or for an evening of drinks with friends, Morty’s Pub is sure to make your experience unforgettable. Take a break from the ordinary and come experience the unique atmosphere of this local pub.

Why We Recommend

Morty’s Pub offers a unique experience with a classic bar atmosphere where you can hear and smell your food as it’s being prepared. Known for its fresh ingredients, whether it’s their burgers served on fresh buns, their superb ‘Soup of the day’ or the perfectly cooked whitefish, the quality is evident in every dish. Pair this with their friendly and personable service, and you have a dining experience that exceeds expectations, making it easy to recommend Morty’s Pub for a memorable meal.

See what people are saying about Morty’s Pub in their Google Reviews.

Contact Information

Phone Number: (715) 779-3996

Address: 108 Rittenhouse Avenue Bayfield, WI 54814

Service Options: Dine-In, Takeout, and Delivery

advertisment

5. Portside Bar and Restaurant

Bar & Grill, Mid-Range Meals, Alcohol Friendly

Portside Bar and Restaurant

Portside Bar and Restaurant is a unique dining experience located on the shores of Lake Superior in Bayfield, Wisconsin. With stunning views of the lake and a cozy atmosphere, Portside Bar and Restaurant is the perfect spot to enjoy a delicious meal with friends and family.

The menu offers a combination of classic American dishes with a modern twist. From seafood to steaks, burgers, and sandwiches, there is something for everyone. The restaurant also offers a great selection of craft beers and local wines from the area.

Whether you’re looking for a romantic dinner for two or a family gathering, Portside Bar and Restaurant is the perfect place to go. Enjoy a delicious meal while taking in the beautiful views of Lake Superior. Visit the Portside Bar and Restaurant today and experience a truly unique dining experience.

Why We Recommend

Portside Bar and Restaurant stands out with its remarkable ability to accommodate and cater to special events, making it an ideal choice for gatherings such as wedding receptions. Their kitchen delivers an array of delectable meals ranging from unique seafood creations to traditional meat and potatoes dishes, all prepared by an experienced chef. Additionally, their clam chowder and fresh whitefish or trout have earned exceptional praises. The enhanced dining experience after recent renovations, coupled with the breathtaking views, make Portside a destination that never disappoints.

Contact Information

Phone Number: (715) 779-5360

Address: 34480 Port Superior Road Bayfield, WI 54814

6. The Creamery Bar

Bar & Grill, Mid-Range Meals, Alcohol Friendly

The Creamery Bar

The Creamery Bar is a one-of-a-kind bar located in the heart of Bayfield, Wisconsin. Located at 31 S 1st Street, The Creamery Bar is a newly renovated bar that has been owned locally for over 20 years. It features a unique atmosphere with a full bar and a variety of food options.

The Creamery Bar has a unique atmosphere that can accommodate a variety of activities. Guests can enjoy live music, pool, trivia nights, karaoke, and more. The bar also hosts special events such as beer and wine tastings, themed nights, and other activities.

The Creamery Bar also offers a full bar with a selection of beers, wines, and spirits. The bar also serves up a variety of food options, including appetizers, sandwiches, burgers, and desserts. Whether you’re looking for a place to relax with friends or a spot to let loose and have some fun, The Creamery Bar is the perfect place to go.

Why We Recommend

The Creamery Bar is renowned for its quintessential hometown bar ambiance, welcoming both locals and visitors year-round. It provides an impressive selection of draft beers and prides itself on its friendly staff and clean environment, with particular commendations for the modern bathrooms. Although its food offering is simple with frozen pizzas, it’s notably satisfying, making The Creamery Bar a must-visit spot for those who appreciate a casual environment to relax, watch sports, and enjoy a drink.

See what people are saying about The Creamery Bar in their Google Reviews.

Contact Information

Phone Number: (715) 913-0180

Address: 31 S 1st St, Bayfield, WI 54814

Service Options: Dine-In and Takeout

advertisment

7. The Pickled Herring

Bar & Grill, Mid-Range Meals, Alcohol Friendly

The Picked Herring

The Pickled Herring is a unique travel destination nestled in the quaint town of Bayfield, Wisconsin. Located at 1 Rittenhouse Ave, this business offers an experience unlike any other in the area.

The Pickled Herring is a specialty seafood restaurant that serves up the best local catch. With a focus on local and sustainable seafood, the restaurant provides guests with a wide variety of dishes that are sure to please any palate. From their fresh fish tacos to their savory fish and chips, their menu is sure to leave guests wanting more.

The restaurant also offers a variety of activities for guests to enjoy. From kayaking, fishing, and sailing to camping, biking, and hiking, The Picked Herring has something for everyone. Whether you’re looking for an adventure or a relaxing getaway, The Pickled Herring is the perfect place to spend your vacation. Come experience the best of Bayfield and enjoy the freshest seafood in town!

Why We Recommend

The Pickled Herring offers a spectacular dining experience with exceptional service, highlighted by their mind-blowing fish fry and flawlessly cooked steak. Patrons will relish in the beautiful views of the lake, adding to the overall warm and welcoming ambiance. Even during peak times, the establishment’s innovative system enables guests to explore the downtown and waterfront shops, making the waiting time part of the enjoyable experience.

See what people are saying about The Pickled Herring in their Google Reviews.

Contact Information

Phone Number: (715) 779-3330

Address: 1 Rittenhouse Ave, Bayfield, WI 54814

Service Options: Dine-In and Takeout

8. Pier Plaza Restaurant

American, Mid-Range Meals, Alcohol Friendly

Pier Plaza Restaurant

Pier Plaza Restaurant is a well-established family-owned and operated business located in downtown Bayfield. The restaurant has been passed down for four generations and has a rich history of serving up delicious cuisine to locals and tourists alike. With a prime location right by the pier, visitors can enjoy their meals while taking in breathtaking views of Lake Superior.

The menu at Pier Plaza Restaurant is diverse, with a range of options to cater to all tastes. From classic American dishes like burgers and sandwiches to seafood favorites like fish tacos and clam chowder, there’s something for everyone. The restaurant also offers a selection of beer, wine, and cocktails to complement your meal.

Whether you’re looking for a casual lunch spot or a place to enjoy a special dinner with friends and family, Pier Plaza Restaurant is a must-visit. With its friendly staff, welcoming atmosphere, and delicious food, it’s no wonder this restaurant has been a Bayfield staple for so many years.

Why We Recommend

The Pier Plaza Restaurant stands out for its exceptional service and friendly staff, where even the smallest guests are given the royal treatment. Their menu impresses with delicious dishes like the highly recommended Chicken Alfresco and substantial appetizers such as poutine and fish cakes that can easily satisfy a group. The restaurant demonstrates an unwavering commitment to customer satisfaction, promptly addressing any issues and exceeding expectations every step of the way.

See what people are saying about the Pier Plaza Restaurant in their Google Reviews.

Contact Information

Phone Number:  (715) 779-3330

Address: 1 Rittenhouse Ave, Bayfield, WI 54814

Service Options: Dine-In, Takeout, and Delivery

9. Greunke’s Restaurant

Diner, Mid-Range Meals, Alcohol Friendly

Greunkes Restaurant

Looking for a family-friendly dining experience in Bayfield? Look no further than Greunke’s Restaurant! This establishment is known for its collection of memorabilia that covers all of its walls, which takes diners back in time as they enjoy a meal from late April through October. Greunke’s offers a full menu that includes some of Americans’ favorite foods, from the “best breakfast in town” featuring classic dishes like oatmeal with raisins and brown sugar, to homemade granola and their famous Greunke’s Eggs Benedict.

But it’s not just breakfast that Greunke’s is known for. Their lunch menu is filled with classics like burgers, sandwiches, salads, and even a hearty Blue Plate Special. And for those looking for something a little more unique, they also serve fresh Lake Superior trout and whitefish, along with homemade soups, whitefish livers, and a traditional Wisconsin Fish Boil. Don’t forget to leave room for dessert, as Greunke’s is also known for their fresh fruit pies, including strawberry and raspberry shortcake. Wash it all down with a fine wine or a beer on tap, or indulge in a hand-dipped milkshake or malt.

Why We Recommend

Greunke’s Restaurant is a must-visit for its well-executed dishes, especially their flavorful Summer Special pizza and impeccably prepared trout and whitefish. They provide a range of drinks to complement their menu, including both sweet and dry wines and a generous selection of beers. Notably, it is also lauded for catering to dietary preferences like gluten-free options, all in a setting that radiates a charming, casual old-world vibe.

See what people are saying about the Greunke’s Restaurant in their Google Reviews.

Contact Information

Phone Number: (800) 245-3072

Address: 17 Rittenhouse Avenue PO Box 768 Bayfield, WI 54814

Service Options: Dine-In

10. Wonderstate Cafe

Coffee Shop, Mid-Range Meals, Alcohol-Free

Wonderstate Coffee Bayfield

Wonderstate Cafe is a popular coffee shop located in the scenic Bayfield area. The business prides itself on offering the finest, organic, and equitably sourced coffee that is sure to satisfy the discerning tastes of coffee connoisseurs. Whether you’re looking for a classic espresso or something more adventurous like a handcrafted pour-over, Wonderstate Coffee has got you covered.

What sets Wonderstate Cafe apart from the competition is its commitment to creating a welcoming and inclusive community through the power of coffee. The business believes that coffee has the power to spark a moment, start a conversation, and bring people together. So if you’re looking for a great cup of coffee in a warm and inviting atmosphere, look no further than Wonderstate Cafe in Bayfield.

Why We Recommend

Wonderstate Cafe stands out as a premier coffee destination offering exceptional service and high-quality beverages, like their unique Cold Coffee Float or a finely crafted cappuccino. Known for their exquisite iced salted caramel latte and an inviting, spacious ambiance with free wifi, it’s also a spot to indulge in delectable baked goods, including the highly-praised cardamom cookies. For bagel and lox enthusiasts, their offerings are unparalleled, featuring buttery lox and perfectly crusted bagels that hit all the right notes.

See what people are saying about Wonderstate Cafe in their Google Reviews.

Contact Information

Phone Number: (715) 913-0330
Address: 117 Rittenhouse Ave, Bayfield, WI 54814

Service Options: Dine-In and Takeout

About the Author
about matthew
Matthew Mellinger
Hey there! I'm Matthew, and I'm a passionate traveler who loves to explore the US with my family of four. I'm excited to share my experiences and tips on how to make the most of your trips while traveling in the US.

More to Explore in Bayfield

linkedin facebook pinterest youtube rss twitter instagram facebook-blank rss-blank linkedin-blank pinterest youtube twitter instagram